| 2008-09 MIDDLETOWN VARSITY | No. | Player's Name | Gr. | School Attending |
| Weston Barrett | |||
| Jacob Bolton | |||
| Leland Creadick | |||
| Tommy Evich | |||
| Zachary Fontenot | |||
| Ian Grife | |||
| Howie Kalamets | |||
| Dakota Martin | |||
| Brad Miller | |||
| Jack Panther | |||
| Brian Schumm | |||
| Zach Welch | |||
| Sean Wenner | |||
| Jason Wiles | |||
| HEAD COACH: Ken Oursler | |||
| 2008-09 MIDDLETOWN JAYVEE | No. | Player's Name | Gr. | School Attending |
| Colson Kirchner | |||
| Brent Leber | |||
| Chandler Redmond | |||
| Nick Welch | |||
| Sam Bladey | |||
| Chase Hoffman | |||
| Brian Kilonsky | |||
| Austin Main | |||
| Ben Panther | |||
| Timothy Pirrone | |||
| Bradley Rinehart | |||
| Tim Schmacher | |||
| Nicholas Yancey | |||
| HEAD COACH: Darin Gordon | |||